GM Guide: The Ultimate Sacrifice

Hello everyone, welcome.  Today I am sharing a post I found on the Fantasy Flight Website about GM’ing an rpg Campaign where players are called to make the ultimate sacrifice.  The following text is an excerpt and I encourage you to click the link back to the full article to have a read as it is full of good stuff.  My thoughts will appear after the excerpt (In fact my thoughts may not make sense if you don’t read the full article).  Images used on this article are from the Fantasy Flight website, and the author of the article is Bryan Young.  He writes in support of Star Wars RPGs, and uses the Star Wars Universe as a basis.  I should warn you, it is a bit spoilery about Rogue One if you haven’t seen it.


“Saw Gerrera used to say, one fighter with a sharp stick and nothing left to lose can take the day. They have no idea we’re coming. They have no reason to expect us. If we can make it to the ground, we’ll take the next chance. And the next. On and on until we win… or the chances are spent.”
–Jyn Erso

Like Star Wars™ fans around the world, we’re eagerly looking forward to Episode VIII. At the same time, we’re delighted simply to live in this new age of Star Wars riches. Constantly growing with new movies, television shows, novels, comics, and more, the Star Wars galaxy is larger and brighter than ever before.

It’s also more diverse. Recent materials have focused on both a greater diversity of characters and styles. And while the Star Wars galaxy was always full of potential for stories of all shapes, sizes, tones, and themes, we’re seeing more of them realized than ever before. From the expansion of the classic Star Wars saga presented by The Force Awakens, to the formation of the Rebellion in Star Wars Rebels, to the gritty war genre stylings of Rogue One, there’s more here than ever before.

via GM Guide: The Ultimate Sacrifice – Fantasy Flight Games


So now that you have read Bryan’s thoughts, I am going to write in response to it.  (Hmm, I knew that degree in English Literature would come in handy some day…)

I love the concept.  I can see the awesome potential of playing a campaign where the players are maneuvered into a situation where there is no real way out for them, their very own Kobayashi Maru (Star Trek Reference – the Kobayashi Maru is the unwinnable scenario that Starfleet uses to train cadets on the command track to learn that there isn’t always a way out.  James Kirk is the only person to ever win…).  I think something like this would be intense and emotional, handled correctly.  That all being said, I have additions to Bryan’s article that I feel are missing.

Expectations – This is the first part I would disagree with.  I actually think there is something to be said for telling the players that they are going to be playing a short, fast paced intense campaign.  I would definitely tell the players it is a one off adventure, but I don’t think I would tell them they are being sent on a suicide mission.  In fact, keeping in the Star Wars universe, there would probably be an escape plan – a commandeered Lambda shuttle or smugglers that have been paid off to exfiltrate the team.  At the end of act 2 of the story, when the players are thoroughly embroiled in their task, that is when I would pull the rug from under their feet.  The Shuttle is impounded, the smuggler is discovered and the victim of a Star Destroyer Turbo Laser bombardment, whatever.  Perhaps I leave a method for characters to survive, but doing so assures mission failure – basically, they can’t do both. Some people might balk at the idea of keeping something like this from their players as their players might actually not like the idea of a no win situation.  I have three thoughts on that.  Firstly, if you suspect your group would need to be told that their characters will die by the end of the story I would argue that perhaps this is not the type of adventure for them.  That isn’t being snobby, it is simply an acknowledgement that players have different expectations.  If players want to invest a lot of time in their characters, or a lot of time in becoming super powerful heroes, then this is not for them.  If they are more focused on the story told, then perhaps it is.  Only the GM can judge that.  The second comment I would make is that I don’t tell my players what the finale is for any other adventure before we start (though I do ask if any subject matter is off limits) so why would I reveal that the player sacrifice is the finale this time?  And finally, the game is more intense, and arguably better, if the “Heroic Sacrifice” is chosen by the players.  Player agency then dictates sacrifice, making it more heroic (in my view)

Emotional Investment – I would do my utmost to make it personal for at least one of the players.  Have their character experience the horrors of the war up close and personal, so that they become emotionally invested more in victory than survival.  This could be the old cliche of the dead mentor, or loss of parents such as Obi Wan Kenobi and Luke’s aunt and uncle in Star Wars.  Be warned, this can backfire.  Emotional investment is great when it leads to unexpected leadership from one of the characters.  It can also lead to stubborn pigheaded behaviour by a character that can be destructive to the group – and not in a blaze of glory kinda way.

Prologue/Epilogue – For something like this I would definitely do a prologue and an epilogue.  The prologue introduces the characters and part of their backstory, and it is at this point that I would force a character to suffer some form of loss, to bring them emotionally into the story.  The epilogue is done once the sacrifice is complete.  The players are likely dead by this stage, however the epilogue is a window into what happened next.  So, if the mission was to sabotage an Imperial Airbase in an asteroid field before a medical convoy enters the system, then I would show the convoy arriving unimpeded, with their supplies being distributed to the folks needing help.  I might even have the convoy leader transmitting a thank you, never realising there is no one left to hear it.  Equally, if the players were left a way out that would assure mission failure I would use the epilogue to show their escape, and even any benefits they might have reaped by escaping.  I would also show the convoy being shot to pieces and the consequences of their failure.

I remember a homebrew game I played, using various 80s movie icons.  Jareth, the Goblin king, recruited Daniel (the Karate Kid), Edgar Frog (Lost Boys), Jack Burton (Big Trouble in Little China) and Data (From the Goonies – played by me) to go to the Tron Realm to “Rescue” a child from Clu.  I should say all the player characters were about 20 years on from the films, so Data as an adult etc.  As the story progressed we realised the Goblin King’s intentions were not honourable, but that didn’t stop Jack Burton making a deal with him to abduct the child in exchange for a reward.  The deal was struck and Burton managed to summon a horde of Goblins at the right time, stealing the child.  A portal was left for us to leave, to go back to the real world and our families, knowing that what we had done had actually disrupted the Tron World.  3 of 4 characters returned home.  But Data stayed.  He wasn’t doomed to die, but he was almost certainly trapped if he didn’t leave then and there, but he couldn’t leave the folks of Tron World to the disruption his group had caused.  So, whilst three PCs returned home at the end of the adventure, I chose to have Data remain.  His finale, his epilogue was to have him walk into the Tron World whilst the GM camera remained motionless – he got further and further away until I couldn’t see him any more.  But it was ok, because Goonies never say die!  Truthfully, I do not believe the adventure was set up as an opportunity for characters to sacrifice themselves heroically.  However, if it had been I think it would have had less impact if I had known it was coming.

So, those are my thoughts.  What are yours?  Have you played in a heroic sacrifice campaign?  Would you play or run one given the opportunity?  And would you want to know it was coming?

Share your thoughts in the comments!

, , ,

3 thoughts on “GM Guide: The Ultimate Sacrifice

  1. Haha, funny before I even read it, I was thinking of the Kobyashi Maru scenario. Cool to see it appear on your article. Can’t say that I have ever played in a campaign like that, but it does really appeal to me. If there is one thing I love in both movie, literature etc, it’s the no win situation where the heroes are faced with impossible odds to beat (And somehow still manage to save the day). Would be cool to play in a campaign like that. As usual: great post! 😊

    1. Thanks for reading! I have to ask. Would you want to know that the game was built around an unwinnable/self sacrifice situation? Or would you want to choose?

      1. I think part of the suspense would ne not knowing right from the start. If you are part way in the game though, that would be really cool. Suddenly hearing that the odds are stacked against you a lot, would certainly make the hairs on the bsck of my neck rise up 😂😂

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.